Creative Toolbox - all about creative tools for creative people
« Back to blog

FreeHand vs Illustrator

In the left corner, an oldie that hasn't been updated since 2004. In the right, Illustrator CS4, the modern, up-to-date, heavy weight champ.

It's interesting to see real world examples and how well FreeHand accomplishes them while Illustrator CS4 still doesn't seem to have a clue. It's as if the developers of Illustrator don't actually use it while the Macromedia developers of FreeHand MX did use it. It's also sad to see such innovative features and workflows killed off when Adobe acquired Macromedia and decided FreeHand should die and Illustrator should live on.

What bugs me about this isn't that they decided to kill one off in favor of another but I really wish that with all these causalities of the Creative Suite, Adobe would've folded in the best features of both. Why doesn't Fireworks have any of the cool features found in ImageReady? Or why doesn't Dreamweaver have the nice, familiar UI of GoLive along with the better implementation of Smart Objects of GoLive? I could go on but you see what I'm getting at. If Adobe thinks it's best to kill one competing app in favor of another, at least bring over the cool features of the killed app into the app that lives on.

Hat tip to Gedeon of Iconfactory for pointing these videos out to me via Twitter. Read about their Top 5 Illustrator Pet Peeves. It's an oldie but a goodie. Sadly, Illustrator CS4 still doesn't address most of them. And if you're a FreeHand fan/advocate, be sure to check out the Free FreeHand organization.

Loading mentions Retweet

Comments (2)

Jan 19, 2010
FELIPE GARCIA said...
If we go back in time since freehand did the same things in less confussing way than A.I., it was in early nineties; so we returned on time at least 15 years. CS series killed the enemy and bought time to make more money instead to give better features to users.
Jan 19, 2010
George Penston said...
I agree. Now looking at what Adobe has done you wonder how the government allowed such a thing. Buying your competition and then killing off their competing products is just the kind of thing I thought the government was supposed to protect us, the consumers, against.

Leave a comment...

 
To leave a comment on this posterous, please login by clicking one of the following.
Posterous-login     Connect     twitter